Navigating the fragmented US approach to AI governance: What FDA guidance, State legislation, and divergence from the EU AI Act mean for regulatory teams

AdobeStock_459536022 - main image

Abstract

Artificial intelligence (AI) governance is developing along different paths in the United States (US) and the European Union (EU). While the EU has developed a horizontal, risk-based framework through the AI Act, the US approach remains distributed across sector-specific federal oversight, State legislation and evolving federal policy. For life sciences organisations, the resulting compliance picture is quite complex. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is developing lifecycle and evidence expectations for AI used in medical devices and drug development, while US States impose their own requirements concerning automated decision-making, healthcare communications, transparency and human review. At the same time, the US is building out its national AI policy and advocating for greater national uniformity.

This article examines the emerging US framework, contrasts it with the EU AI Act, and considers how regulatory teams can build governance systems capable of addressing divergent global requirements without unnecessary duplication of controls, evidence and oversight.

How to read this journal article 

Thank you for visiting Regulatory Rapporteur. Journal articles are restricted to TOPRA members and registered users.

If you are a TOPRA member, or have already registered for limited free access, log in now (Option 1 below).

Not yet a member? You can either join TOPRA (Option 2 below) or register to view limited content for free (Option 3 below).

1. LOGIN

Already a TOPRA member?

Log in now using your MyTOPRA credentials, for unlimited access to all Regulatory Rapporteur journal articles, the online archive and latest industry news and podcasts.

Renew your TOPRA membership for 2026 here.

Already registered for free content?

If you are not a TOPRA member but have already created an account to access limited free content, log in here using your registered user email and password.

Login

2. JOIN TOPRA

TOPRA membership

Become a TOPRA member and join our global regulatory affairs community.

  • Great savings on our events and training.
  • Be part of our dynamic international community.
  • Contribute to the profession.
  • Grow your skills and knowledge.
  • Take your career to the next level.
Become a member

3. REGISTER FOR FREE

Want free access to selected content?

Register now to continue to access industry news, editorials and podcasts plus one member-only journal article each month.

  • Create your own library to save your favourite content.
Create a free account